Some months your phone barely rings, and the idea of paying a fixed fee for calls that never came feels daft. Other months it doesn't stop. So is a pay per call answering service the cheaper way to go, or a monthly plan? If your calls are few and patchy, paying per call often comes out cheaper on paper. Once you're reliably getting close to a plan's allowance, and that plan works out no dearer per call than the rate you've been quoted, the monthly plan catches up.
We should be upfront: we only sell monthly plans, each with a published price for every call over the allowance. So read this knowing which side of the fence we're on. We've tried to do the sums fairly anyway, because a plan you resent paying for is a plan you'll cancel.
Your break-even number, in one division
There's one sum that settles most of this. Take the monthly price of the plan you're looking at and divide it by the per-call price you've been quoted elsewhere. The answer is the number of calls a month where the two cost exactly the same. Fewer calls than that and pay per call is cheaper. More, and the monthly plan is.
Before you trust the answer, check it comes out no bigger than the number of calls the plan actually includes. If it's bigger, the plan won't catch up at any sensible number of calls, because once you're past the allowance each extra call costs about the same either way, so most of the gap you started with just stays put.
To keep the numbers simple, let's use £2 a call, which happens to be our own rate on Light once you're past its allowance. Our Light plan costs £59 and covers your first 30 calls each month, and £59 divided by £2 is 29.5, so the line sits right at about 30 calls, which is exactly Light's allowance. That's the one plan of ours where the sum works out neatly against £2 a call. Essential answers exactly like Light, just with more calls included, so at £2 a call it simply costs more. Growth and Premium are a different thing, because you're paying for more to happen on each call, like the job getting booked in, and their break-even comes out above the allowance, so for those the sum won't help much.
Run a few months through it and you can see where each one wins:
- A quiet month of 10 calls costs you £20 if you're paying per call, while Light still costs the full £59.
- A steady month of 30 calls comes to £60 per call against £59 on Light, which is near enough a draw.
- A busy month of 45 calls is £90 per call, and on Light it's the £59 plus 15 extra calls at £2, so £89.
Notice what happens above the allowance. On Light, at a matching £2, the plan never costs you more in a busy month, because every call over 30 is £2 either way. All the difference sits in the quiet months, when you're paying for calls you didn't get. So the real question is how many quiet months you have in a year.
Count your calls before you choose anything
It's tempting to guess your call numbers, and a guess tends to lean towards whatever answer you're hoping for. Spend a fortnight actually counting instead. Your phone's recent calls list already has most of it, including the ones you missed.
Then go through and strike out everything that isn't work: the cold callers, the supplier ringing about a delivery, your mum. What's left is the number that matters, because those are the calls somebody would be answering for you. If you can, mark which ones were new customers, since those are the ones you lose when nobody picks up.
Do it in a normal fortnight if you can, not the week your van was off the road or the week before Christmas. And if your work comes in waves, count in a busy spell as well as a quiet one, because that's where the next bit comes in.
When a pay per call answering service is the cheaper choice
Plenty of trades and seasonal businesses don't really have an average month. If you fix boilers, you already know January and July are different jobs entirely, and that winter rush is exactly why we wrote about the boiler work plumbers miss when nobody answers in the cold months. So look at a whole year, not one month.
Take a lumpy year as an example, with six quiet months at 15 calls, six busy ones at 45, and the same £2 a call as before. Paying per call, that's six months at £30 and six at £90, so £720 for the year. On Light it's six months at £59 and six at £89, which comes to £888.
That's £168 a year in favour of paying per call, and we're not going to pretend otherwise. If your calls look like that, and all you need is a message taken, a straight per-call deal at a similar rate can genuinely be the cheaper option. If your quiet months are nearer 30 calls than 15, though, the gap mostly disappears.
One catch with that maths is that it assumes the per-call quote really is as simple as it looks. Before you trust it, ask three things. What counts as a call: does a wrong number, a hang-up or a sales call cost the same as a real enquiry? Is there a monthly minimum or a standing charge on top of the per-call price? And is the rate the same at 5 calls a month as at 60? Put any extra charges into your sum, then do the division again.
Running it for your own business
The example above uses made-up call counts to show the shape of it. Yours will be different, so run the sum on the back of an envelope with your own figures in it:
- Write down your work calls for a typical quiet month and a typical busy one, and how many of each kind of month you get in a year.
- For the per-call option, multiply each month's calls by the rate you've been quoted, then add the months up.
- For a monthly plan, take the plan price for every month, then add the calls over the allowance at that plan's published rate.
- Add any one-off or standing charges to both totals, spread across the twelve months.
Then compare the two yearly figures, not the monthly ones. A plan that looks expensive in March can easily be the cheaper one by December, and the other way round. If the two totals come out within a few pounds of each other, stop worrying about the price and pick on what happens when the phone rings, because that's the part your customers notice.
What a monthly fee buys besides the calls
Price per call is the easy thing to compare. The harder things are worth a minute too.
Start with knowing your bill. On a monthly plan you know the starting figure before the month begins, and every call over the allowance has a price you can see on the plans page. If you like being able to budget for the year in January, that's worth something, even if it doesn't show up in the sum above.
Then there's the call itself. On Light, the caller leaves a message and you get the details sent over. On Growth, which costs £249 and includes 100 calls and £1.75 for each one after that, somebody ringing for a job can be booked into a free slot while they're still on the line. A job sitting in your diary is worth a lot more than a message, and it doesn't leave you ringing anybody back at nine at night. If you'd like every plan's price broken down per call, we've done that in our guide to what a telephone answering service costs.
And there's the setup. Before your first call is picked up, your forwarding gets sorted, scripts get drawn up for the sorts of calls that come in, and the way you run things gets written down, so the person answering knows your business from the very first ring. That's a single charge at the start, from £49.50 (normally £99).
So which would we pick?
It comes down to what your phone actually does.
Say you get a handful of work calls in most months and only ever need a message taken. A pay-per-call deal could well be cheaper for you, and we'd rather you knew that. Do the division and see.
Once you're steadily getting 30 or more work calls a month, Light at £59 works out cheaper than paying £2 a call, and every one of those calls is picked up by a real person who's been briefed on your business.
Where the calls you're missing are people who want booking in, we'd stop comparing price per call altogether. Work out what one booked job is worth to you, because on Growth what you're really weighing up is how many of those calls end up as jobs in your diary.
Your calls are picked up in Wath upon Dearne, South Yorkshire, and since everything happens down the phone line, your business can be anywhere from Cornwall to Carlisle. If you want to know what actually happens to a call, our telephone answering service page takes you through it step by step. Better still, have a free week on us, no card needed, and use those seven days to get a real count of your calls instead of a guess.
